RAY HADLEY: The Acting Immigration Minister Alan Tudge is in our Canberra studio. Minister, good morning to you.
ALAN TUDGE: Good morning Ray.
RAY HADLEY: Just trying to clear up this anomaly, because when I first started hearing about this Trans-Tasman bubble and people landing in Sydney and then flying into either Melbourne or Perth, I was a bit confused about it. And, of course, I read from a statement you had supplied to us earlier about that, yes, the Trans-Tasman bubble meant people could come to both New South Wales or Northern Territory. I suspect then that meant they couldn't go to either Queensland, in the case of Victoria, Western Australia. But then I read a bit further and say, well, it's not really your problem, it's a problem for the Victorian Government. So, how does it actually work? Just say someone landed yesterday or over the weekend into Sydney, and they had an ongoing ticket with Qantas, Virgin, whatever, to go to Melbourne. Do they just simply come out of international, go to domestic and fly down?
ALAN TUDGE: Yeah. Well, that's right. I mean, as you know, Ray, we look after the international borders, and we ensure that you have a valid passport, or a valid visa if you need one, that we know who you are, done all those checks, and then once you're through the borders, you're into Australia. And in terms of your travel internally; that is up to state governments. Now, our view is that the borders generally, internal borders, generally should be open, but some state governments have decided to close their borders - we know, for example, Queensland has its borders closed for people from New South Wales going into Queensland, unless you have a permit. And so, when you, when a New Zealander, or indeed, an Australian coming from New Zealand lands into Sydney and wants to on travel to Melbourne, they go round to the domestic terminal and they jump on a flight, because the Victorian Government has made no restrictions on internal travel from Sydney to Melbourne.
RAY HADLEY: So, in other words, because the government, the Palaszczuk Government has put the restrictions there, if someone were to come off a flight out of Auckland and try to access Brisbane, they'd be detained at the airport, no doubt, and sent back. So, that's why that would not happen, correct?
ALAN TUDGE: They wouldn't necessarily be sent back because they'd be validly in Australia having passed the international borders effectively at the gates, but unless they had a permit to go into Queensland, the Queensland Government would not allow them to travel on that plane and land in Brisbane.
RAY HADLEY: Sure. Yeah, well, that's the point I'm trying to make. So, the Queensland Government would stop them getting on the plane, or get off the plane, they'd be either sent back or you can go into quarantine if you like. But, you know, effectively when that's over, you'll come straight back to where you came from anyway. So, that doesn't happen in Victoria. Now, I'm interested in this meeting, that Professor Sutton the Chief Medical Officer in Victoria, says he left when it was discussed. And from what I understand from what you've said overnight, there was no opposition from Victoria in relation to this anomaly where people who'd come into Sydney and then just jump on a plane and fly to Melbourne. Is that correct as well?
ALAN TUDGE: Yeah, that's correct. In fact, there were two meetings of the chief medical officers of the country on both the Monday, last Monday, well before the Kiwis arrived, and on the subsequent day. At the first meeting, Professor Sutton was there, the Chief Health Officer from Victoria, as was his deputy, and on the second day, the Chief Health Officer was also present. And on both occasions, the matter of people travelling from New Zealand, landing in Sydney, and on travelling to other jurisdictions was expressly raised. Now, you can't tell me that at both meetings, both the Chief Health Officer and his deputy happen to be absent at the key moments at both meetings. I mean, that would be a real Deidre Chambers coincidence, wouldn't it? But it's…
RAY HADLEY: [Talks over] So, these are Zoom meetings, I presume, these are Zoom meetings where you can mute yourself. I mean, so, the suggestion is that if they're meeting with these medical officers from New Zealand, and also from federally, from the Federal Government, that somehow they missed that discussion. Now, just say they didn't miss the discussion, and they did hear it, could they have then taken steps and said, well, hang on a sec, we're going to be like Queensland, they can't come here unless they have an exemption? Would that have been possible?
ALAN TUDGE: They, technically, yes, but I don't think that they would be able to lawfully do that. And the reason being, that under Victoria's emergency laws which impose all the restrictions, they are only able to do that for medical reasons. And there was no medical reason to restrict a person coming from Sydney into Melbourne via New Zealand- oh, sorry, from New Zealand into- to Melbourne via Sydney…
RAY HADLEY: [Talks over] Sure, sure.
ALAN TUDGE: … Because there hasn't been coronavirus in New Zealand. So the risks of a person being in New Zealand are lower than the risks of a person being in Sydney for a few weeks.
RAY HADLEY: Okay. Let's go to…
ALAN TUDGE: So they wouldn't have had the legal basis, in my view, to do that.
RAY HADLEY: Okay. Let's, well, I mean I think the [indistinct] legal have been thrown out the window here in COVID. People seem to do what they like in terms of state governments or federal governments, as the case may be.
Let's got to Western Australia. Now, the Premier there, I think 23 people arrived in the same circumstances you and I have just described. He's put 22 into quarantine and I think there's a baby that's escaped quarantine. Now, could Victoria have done that? Once the people started arriving, could they have said, well hang on a sec, we need you to go and quarantine. But could they have enacted the same sort of rules as the Premier in WA did?
ALAN TUDGE: Well, I've been informed that indeed the Victorian officials were at Melbourne Airport when these people arrived from New Zealand via Sydney and they had had discussions with the individuals but then made a determination not to quarantine them because they didn't believe that they had the powers to do so because there was no medical risk to quarantine them, because there's zero transmissions in New Zealand.
RAY HADLEY: Well there would have been…
ALAN TUDGE: [Interrupts] This is an important point. I mean, in all of this, in all of this, two important points. One being that some of these people are actually Australian citizens themselves. There may well be ongoing residents of Victoria. So you're talking about potentially Victorians returning home. And they've been in New Zealand, where there's been no community transmission for 14 days. Zippo. Zero. So the risks from them carrying the virus are lower than the risks of an everyday Sydney-sider who decides to travel across the border freely, and they can do so freely today.
RAY HADLEY: Well, they had this fiasco about hotel, you know, quarantine and the current inquiry where no one seems to know what happened. It would be handy if at one stage during their meetings - they seem to meet regularly - if the Chief Health Officer of Victoria, Professor Sutton actually spoke to the Premier and told him before he went to media conferences to mislead the rest of us about what actually transpired and how these people got there, because your explanation is quite plausible and understandable and it appears it's a giant stuff up again by the Victorians. Can I ask you a question without notice?
ALAN TUDGE: Can I make one further point before you do on this, Ray?
RAY HADLEY: Yeah, go on.
ALAN TUDGE: I mean, today I was shown the fact that the Victorian Health and Human Services website expressly says under the heading of travelling to Victoria from New Zealand, that if you are travelling from New Zealand and you've passed all the relevant immigration and biosecurity requirements, then you are able to travel to Victoria and that you do not need to quarantine for 14 days on arrival in Victoria. Their own website expressly says this. And this is why I'm perplexed as to why Daniel Andrews, the Victorian Premier, launched such an aggressive attack on us over the weekend. I mean, we don't want to argue with him over these matters because they were discussed at officials levels. They were agreed by the Victorian Government, according to their own internal emails, according to their own website, there's no issue with Victorians coming in. And so we don't want to necessarily have these disagreements. But he's raised this issue and said very publicly that we're apparently at fault when it seems very clear that they knew about it, consented to it. And their website shows that people can fully do exactly what they did.
RAY HADLEY: Almost on cue, you wouldn't believe it, you started talking about it at 10:25, 9:25 in Queensland. And so at around 9:24 local time, Bill at the Sunshine Coast said, Ray, this is from their website: The Trans-Tasman travel bubble is currently in place between New Zealand and parts of Australia. This allows travellers from New Zealand to arrive at New South Wales and Northern Territory without having to quarantine. Currently, Victorian borders are open. If you're travelling from New Zealand and have passed all the relevant immigration and biosecurity requirements as established by the federal government, New South Wales Government, Northern Territory Government, you're able to travel to Victoria; you don't need to quarantine for 14 days. I mean, Daniel Andrews has not read his own health pronouncement about all of this. So the whole thing's a storm in a teacup.
Now, question without notice. I tried to raise it with Peter Dutton and couldn't get answers. You know that we've got some problems in New South Wales with a bloke called Daryl Maguire, profiting allegedly from visas to Chinese nationals for non-existent jobs, working visas, particularly in the Riverina, where he was the member for Wagga Wagga back then. This question has been asked of me, and I don't know whether you know the answer. Did any people arrive with these illegally obtained visas when they were brought to Australia to work in non-existent jobs? And if so, are they still here? The people I mean.
ALAN TUDGE: I haven't got the answer to that question on hand. This is being addressed in Senate Estimates as we speak, whereby the senior officials from the federal Immigration Department has said they've been cooperating with the New South Wales ICAC. I don't understand what visas that Daryl Maguire was referring to. Because visas are typically issued, obviously, by the federal Immigration Department. There are some state nominated visas which are provided and he may have been referring to those, but we haven't got to the bottom of that yet.
RAY HADLEY: Okay. Alright. Well, hopefully we'll get to the bottom of it; you'll let us know here. Thanks very much for your time.
ALAN TUDGE: Thanks very much, Ray.
RAY HADLEY: Appreciate that. Acting Immigration Minister Alan Tudge.
[End]