Subjects: Working holiday maker visa reforms
MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS, IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP, TONY BURKE:... on behalf of the local operators, tourism and agriculture in the local area, wanting to make sure that we could come up with the best possible outcome for working holiday makers in terms of what it means for the local economy. And I’ve had similar advocacy from regional members around the country.
When I announced at the National Press Club what we would do in terms of bringing down Net Overseas Migration I made clear that we needed to look at every single visa class, and that meant that working holiday makers had to be part of the solution in dealing with getting net overseas migration down to the levels that had been forecast in the budget.
From the day after the speech, myself, the assistance ministers and the department started consultation with industry to work through what is the best landing place to deliver the total numbers that we’re talking about but to do it in a way that works best for industry. I’m really pleased that in that consultation, a series of roundtables and a delegation that Matt Smith brought to Canberra, we’ve been able to come up with an outcome where effectively two things are true: first, I get the Net Overseas Migration numbers and the total number of working holiday makers that I’d announced at the National Press Club, but we do it in a way where regional Australia gets no cut in terms of how many working hours they receive.
Let me explain how we’ve been able to do that. First of all, there’s some extra headspace that I’ve been able to get in working holiday makers because we’ve continued to go on slow processing for UK backpackers, and that’s given us some extra space. The second thing that we’ve been able to do is work on a shift to how many days you have to work in the regions to qualify for the second year. And by increasing that, we’ve been able to end up with the best possible outcome.
So here’s the top line of the changes that we’re announcing today – first of all, anyone who completes their regional work between now and the 28th of February is under the old rules. So if you haven’t completed your regional work between now and the 28th of February, if you get out and do it, nothing has changed for you, the old rules apply.
Secondly, for people who don’t finish by the 28th of February, to qualify for your second year instead of 88 days you’ll have to do 120 days. So that’s instead of three months it will be four months if you haven’t finished by the 28th of February. So that provides a lot more regional work for those people who are in their first year wanting to qualify for their second year.
And the requirement to qualify for your third year of the six months work, that remains the same.
The way we are dealing with the balloting though, we have completely shifted. What we will be doing now is establishing what we will call the regional – what we’ll be calling the next year regional work guarantee – the next year regional work guarantee. From December people will be able to apply for the guarantee, and from January every month we will be issuing these guarantees. What that means is if you receive the guarantee and you do the regional work – either you’ve already done it or you do it subsequently – then you’ve got the guarantee for the next year. And we’ll be issuing those every month, those guarantees.
We’ll be issuing them to make sure that the numbers that I announced of 45,000 year 2 becomes what we get and, secondly, instead of 5,000 for year 3 we will go to 25,000 year 3 backpackers. This creates a very significant shift but also means for the people who are wanting to qualify for their second year, we’re getting more regional days out of them.
Effectively, that means two things come as a result of this announcement: the first thing that happens is the exact net overseas migration numbers that I announced are being able to be delivered. But, secondly, because of the shift from three to four months, the regions will get more workers than they previously had.
Additional to this, as has been said publicly before, we continue to work with the United Kingdom to be able to get a better deal for Australia. Before we came to office there had been an agreement signed with the United Kingdom by the previous government which basically said to qualify for year 2 you didn’t need to do any regional work at all, you just needed to apply. To qualify for year 3 you still didn’t need to do any regional work, you just needed to apply. That is not a good outcome for Australia, and we’ve got constructive conversations that are continuing with the United Kingdom, and I’m optimistic that we’re going to get a much better deal than what was previously negotiated. But because that’s part of a side letter with the trade agreement, that’s a negotiation that continues with the UK.
But even before we get that – to that part of it resolved, what we announce today delivers those two things: more workers for the regions but still the cut to Net Overseas Migration that was forecast in the budget that we need to be able to deliver on.
Once again, I thank Matt Smith for the advocacy and all the different regional members who’ve been out there advocating for these changes, and I’ll hand over to Matt to say a few words before I go to questions.
MATT SMITH: Thank you, Tony. Let’s make no mistake about this – this is a win for the far north, and it was driven by the far north. From the moment this was announced I had a chat to Tony, I had a chat to Mark Olsen. We tried to figure out the best way to get through this get a landing spot that would work for both of our needs for the reduction in migration but to ensure that our region continues to get the workforce that it needs, that surge workforce, the stuff up the Cape, all of that so critically important to the way the far northern economy works.
The fact that we were able to deliver an increase in working days while making that cut is a testament to the work that has been done not just by Tony but by the delegation that was led from the far north down to Canberra. They came with ideas, they came with solutions, and we had open, transparent, sometimes robust and bold conversations, but where we have landed is a testament to the work that these guys have done and the work that we’ve done as a community in advocating to make sure that we get what we need.
To put it into context, from going from 88 days to 120 days, even with the reduction from 57,000 to 45,000 works out an extra thousand years of workforce, which is a massive, massive fillip for the regions. We are going to have the workers. We are now able to give people the surety they need for their businesses, for their farms, for construction, for tourism, for all the things that keep our really fantastic part of the nation going forward.
I want to thank Tony, again, for engaging so constructively not just with me but with all of regional Australia, and particularly the delegation from the far north. And I’m very encouraged by the signs coming out of the UK as well. This is, as I said, a massive, massive win for the regions. We’re getting extra workforce. It’s going to give people the surety that they need going forward, and the grandfathering in until February, you’ve got 103 days, so if you want to get started, get started today. We have plenty of work going right now here in Cairns. If you’re a backpacker and working holiday maker and you want to get that 88 days done, come to Cairns, come to Cairns tomorrow. We’ll find you a job and we’ll get you going. Thank you very much.
BURKE: Thanks, Matt. Happy to go to questions.
JOURNALIST: Are you committing to removing the [indistinct] plan entirely?
BURKE: The guarantee is done through a balloting-style system. So but what we’re effectively changing is the way it had been presumed to run at the time of the original announcement was you do the work and then you go into a draw. What we’ve done now is we’ve allowed people to put their name forward whether they’ve done the work yet or not. At any time during their first visa or their second visa, they can put their name forward, and what that then – what we then issue every month are guarantees. So once you’ve got the guarantee you know if you’ve already done the regional work job done, you’ve got the next year. If you haven’t done the regional work yet, you turn up knowing every day that your position is guaranteed for the next visa.
JOURNALIST: So inevitably [indistinct], you know, left in limbo as to whether they can continue for another [indistinct].
BURKE: Well, the situation right now, anyone who gets their 88 days done between now and the 28th of February, they’re already guaranteed. Between now and the 28th of February, anyone that gets the regional work done, then they exist under the old rules. What will then happen is there will be a system where people every month will be told that they’ve got the guarantee. And that makes sure that everybody in the working – everyone’s who’s a working holiday maker, a backpacker, is in a circumstance where they can apply, they get the guarantee, they turn up knowing if you do the work you get the extra year.
JOURNALIST: You’ve said you’re going to link the cap on the number of backpackers after these new arrangements. But you’ve also committed to these immigration cuts that were announced in September. So where are you going to make up that number from?
BURKE: Yeah, the headspace, you might call it, is already made up because of the slower processing we’ve been doing on UK visas while we’ve been having the negotiations with the United Kingdom. So effectively that’s what’s allowed me, the slower processing – there was some slower processing generally that was happening before the announcement that I made. And we’ve continued the slower processing with UK only since then. That’s provided the space that’s allowed me to go from the 5,000 to the 25,000 in year 3.
JOURNALIST: Did you underestimate how much regional economies rely on backpackers?
BURKE: People rely on every aspect of the immigration system. Let’s not forget, both One Nation and the Coalition, where their effective cuts end up being is to skilled workers. And I think they have completely underestimated what will happen to hospitals all around Australia and age care centres when you make cuts there.
Anything you do has an economic impact. What you need to make sure of is we do need to get net overseas migration down. That’s what’s forecast in the budget. That’s what we’re doing. That needs to happen. The question then – and that’s what we’ve been working through with industry – is how do you do that in a way that gives industry the best landing point. And the announcement that we make today gives us exactly what we need in terms of reduction of total people in terms of migration but at the same time gives more regional working days for backpackers. It’s a perfect landing for industry, and I’m very grateful for all the consultation on implementation that’s happened over the last month or so.
JOURNALIST: Will you admit your government [Indistinct]
BURKE: We said – I said that consultation started the day after on how do you land this. And effectively the total numbers that I announced are completely unchanged. The total numbers haven’t changed. We work with industry in making sure that we get the best possible landing. Best possible landing for the economy, best possible landing for jobs, also best possible landing for every tourist who wants to come to one of the most fantastic parts of the world where we are right now and has a situation of making sure that all the services are able to run. Getting that landing place is something where the engagement with industry has been fantastic, and I’m very grateful for it.
JOURNALIST: Are you actively renegotiating the free trade agreement with the UK [indistinct]?
BURKE: I’m not the Trade Minister. What I know is that the conversations are happening specifically on how we can get agreement with the United Kingdom on having a different sort of obligation than what is currently there for UK backpackers. And the conversations, the conversations I can say, both between myself and their Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, and the conversations between our Prime Minister and the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Andy Burnham, have been going very well. But until every detail is landed, I’m not going to get ahead of an announcement. We’re already in a situation simply as a result of what I’m announcing right now where the Net Overseas Migration numbers that I announced are being delivered and we are getting more workers for the regions than ever before.
JOURNALIST: How long do you expect those negotiations with the UK to last?
BURKE: With the UK? Because – the thing that you want to make sure of is there is no world where we want to get retaliation because there are big benefits for the nation in any trade agreement. But the United Kingdom have a good understanding of the issues that we need to resolve. So I’m not going to put a time line on it, but I will say I’m very optimistic about how those conversations have been going.
JOURNALIST: And under the [indistinct] proposal and, I guess, the last few months of anxiety in regional communities and among backpackers maybe has fractured your government’s relationship with international visitors?
BURKE: Look, it’s been interesting – the figures that we’ve got in the department in terms of number of backpackers who are still applying has actually held up. So I know there’s lots of anecdotal information that’s out there and I respect that. But in terms of the actual raw numbers that we have of applications, the applications have been holding up. And I think you’ll find after an announcement like we’re making right now the behavioural change of people – first of all of people wanting to – who can get things done by getting their days done by the end of February, I reckon you’ll see that behavioural change immediately. And once expressions of interest are open in December, I reckon you’ll see the people who haven’t finished by the 28th of February applying for the next year guarantee but with the knowledge that the next year guarantee will be the four months, the 120 days, rather than the 88 to get from year 1 to year 2.
JOURNALIST: How crucial was the delegation in your decision?
BURKE: How?
JOURNALIST: How crucial was the delegation from the far north in your decision?
BURKE: Can I say the group from the far north was the first group to raise with me the concept of changing from the 88 days to something higher. Now, not every stakeholder group was supportive of going higher, so there were discussions of could we go all the way to six months, and some of the stakeholder groups outside of the far north were worried that you might find it harder to get people into areas like horticulture and things like that. But by landing at four months we still get more days than we currently have, so we still get a better outcome for regional workforce, but we don’t carry any of the risks that some stakeholders were concerned about in going further than four months.
JOURNALIST: So under these new rules [indistinct] four months to then reapply. What does that regional work look like for backpackers in their second and or third year?
BURKE: The sort of work that you would be doing is the same as what you’re already doing; there’s just an extra month to be able to qualify for the second year. So, you know, when backpackers have been out, whether it’s fruit picking, whether it’s working in hospitality, whether it’s doing some work with, you know, scaffolding or other areas like that – there’s a series of different jobs that backpackers have been doing all around Australia and, in particular, in the regions. It’s good for the economy, they’re popular in the local area, we need to – we needed to make sure that nationally backpackers were part of the answer in Net Overseas Migration.
But, you know, at the time that I made the announcement in the Press Club I’ll say this: I didn’t expect that we would find a landing point as good as what we are announcing today where we, in fact, end up with more days of regional work than we started with while still bringing total migration numbers down.
JOURNALIST: How many months do they have to do [indistinct]?
BURKE: Second year to third year is still six months. No change.
JOURNALIST: Can you rule out [indistinct] to ensure you reach the migration target?
BURKE: Yes, the Opposition and One Nation have both said to go harder on international students. I’m very worried about that, if you were to do that. The tertiary education institutions have relied on international students largely because they were told to. Now, a number of institutions in particular weren’t keeping pace with student housing, and that’s created a problem where you had students coming from overseas, sometimes bringing whole families with them, and finding that there wasn’t student accommodation available and going straight into the domestic housing market.
That has been one of the pressures that we’ve wanted to alleviate. We’ve done that in two ways: first, by bringing down through planning levels the total number of overseas student applications. That’s been working. But, secondly, by limiting the capacity for people to bring family members with them. And I’ve got to say, in making the family member rule, if an Australian falls in love with someone, they will wait more than two years for their partner to join them. To think that an international student could just get their partner with them from day one didn’t seem like a fair arrangement. So those changes that we’ve made I think get that balance right. If you go too hard no-one will thank you for regional educational institutions start to fall over because of decisions.
And can I say what the Coalition and One Nation have proposed, they would be looking straight down the barrel of that. And, you know, the number of jobs that are often attached to those institutions, it’s not just the academics, it’s also cleaners, it’s trades people, there’s people who look after the grounds, there’s all the hospitality that runs around university towns. There are a lot of jobs at stake if you go too hard, and I think the numbers that the Opposition and the One Nation have put forward in going much, much harder than us on international students, I think they’d have devastating impacts for jobs and the economy.
JOURNALIST: You said that there are still [indistinct] amount of applications for that working holiday visa, but there was a backlog before, and that led to [indistinct] not being able to get workers in that critical harvest period and other regional industries. So has that process sped up now?
BURKE: The process – I haven’t sped up the process with respect to the UK. With respect to us processing applications as they come in for all other parts of working holiday maker, I indicated publicly at the time of the Press Club speech that we were returning to normal pace on those.
JOURNALIST: You’ve said you’re concerned about going harder on international students, but is the impact not equal if not greater for regional communities relying on tourism and hospitality which the roles are mostly taken up mostly by backpackers?
BURKE: This is why you need to make sure that you spread the responsibility of reducing net overseas migration across a series of visa classes. You can’t get one visa class to do all the work. And there are some visa classes where, you know, if you made cuts to nurses coming from overseas or aged care workers coming from overseas, the impacts on services that Australians have a right to believe will be available in this country just collapses. So there was a need to do something in working holiday makers, and we’ve found a way of doing it where the regions actually get more workers, not fewer.
JOURNALIST: [Indistinct] a lot of conversations with regional operators before announcing these changes?
BURKE: Most of the conversations that were happening before the Press Club address were relating to the go-slow, effectively the slower processing that we were doing and people were wanting that to be sped up. That part of it was sped up. But what we announced at the same time was the 45 and the 5,000 at the time. Obviously that 5,000 I’ve announced today goes up to 25,000.
[Voiceover]
BURKE: We – the consultation has all occurred and we’re making the announcement before the regulation was due to be implemented anyway. So the timing of the change is exactly the same but the landing place is so much better than where we thought we’d be able to be. And I’m very grateful. It’s not simply people engaging in consultation; it’s the way they engage in consultation. And as I said at the start, the group that Matt brought down was the first group to propose let’s change that three months to something higher, and I think that’s really been the key to the announcement today. Without that the announcement today would be a shift in terms of some of the numbers from the Press Club, but you wouldn’t have the total improvement in how many days we were getting of regional work that we’re able to get. That’s only possible because of the consultation. And, can I say, that started with the far north.
JOURNALIST: [Indistinct] backpackers might be included in that like they were with the UK trade deal? [Indistinct] at the moment?
BURKE: Look, there are already with the European Union a series of working holiday maker agreements. And obviously one of the changes that we’ve made in recent times is, you know, for years everybody from both sides of politics viewed the numbers that were in the budget for net overseas migration as forecasts. And so what we have changed now is the concept that these are figures we are now aiming to arrive at. That’s a big shift. It means my job is quite different to the job of any immigration minister before me. There’s a whole lot of the system that’s demand driven and there previously hasn’t been an expectation that the numbers in the budget would be something that were aimed at – aimed for. So that context changes effectively how we look at these issues in trade agreements.
So any immigration issue in trade agreements now needs to work on the basis that we have an expectation that there are numbers we are actually aiming to deliver in the budget rather than it simply being a forecast.
JOURNALIST: If UK [indistinct] propose [indistinct]?
BURKE: Sorry?
JOURNALIST: If UK backpackers do have to do that regional work requirement, where would they go [indistinct]?
BURKE: The issue of where the UK backpackers principle lands, I don’t want to get too far in front of the negotiation. But it is public that the conversations we’ve been having have been about there being a regional work obligation, which does not currently exist. So if we land that, can I say we’re already as a result of the announcement today, we already have more regional days of work from working holiday makers than we’ve ever had before. That’s already there as a result of today’s announcement. If we land something with the United Kingdom, it gets even stronger. Thanks very much everybody.
[END]